False copyright strike by Media Nov Records blocked musician Samantha Shokin's video on YouTube
YouTube took down musician Samantha Shokin's video featuring a cover of a publicly available Bulgarian folk song following a false copyright claim by the company Media Nov Records. YouTube rejected both of her counterclaims, the company does not respond to contact attempts, and its website appears to be AI-generated.
Musician and writer Samantha Shokin uploaded a cover of the publicly available Bulgarian folk song "Bre Petrunko" to YouTube in 2022. Over four years, the video gained 125 thousand views, and her voice appeared without her consent as a sample in dozens of electronic tracks, sold among others by distributor Loopmasters in the "Folk Legends" package – one of the tracks created this way has over 4 million views. After being notified, the distributor acknowledged the situation, apologized, and granted Shokin royalties.
Last summer, however, the company Media Nov Records filed a copyright strike against her original video on YouTube, and the platform took the video down, even though it is a work from the public domain with no actual rights holder. Shokin filed two counterclaims; YouTube rejected both, stating it was "not clear whether there is a valid reason," and referred her to contact the company that YouTube had identified as the rights holder. According to findings by 404 Media, Media Nov Records does not respond to phone calls or emails, and its website appears to be AI-generated.
On its website, Media Nov Records states that it uses "advanced AI" to identify music and for automated DMCA takedowns and Content ID management, even though, according to company records in Ireland, it was established roughly a year ago (shareholders list addresses in Turkey, while the company's website lists addresses in Los Angeles and Dublin). 404 Media tracked down four YouTube channels operated by this company with hundreds of videos featuring AI-generated graphics and music, mostly with low view counts.
Why it matters
The case shows that the automated system for assessing copyright claims on the YouTube platform can block even content with no actual rights holder and reject appeals without any human review. For content creators, this represents a real risk of losing a video and monetization with no means of effective defense; for companies in distribution and rights management, it serves as a warning that such tools can be abused by newly established entities with no verifiable track record.
Two audiences, two different impacts
What this means
For individuals
Musician Samantha Shokin shows that YouTube's automated copyright claims system can block even a publicly available work with no actual rights holder, and that an appeal (counterclaim) can be rejected with no way to contact a human on either YouTube's side or the side of the company that filed the claim.
For a business
The company Media Nov Records, registered in Ireland for roughly a year, with shareholders listing addresses in Turkey, abused the automated copyright claims system on the YouTube platform to block a legitimate video.
Risks and complianceCheck the original
Event sources
only one source so far · 1 publisher, 1 independent. We count feeds from the same owner only once.