Detector Pangram flagged an award-winning novel as 99 percent AI-generated, the publisher backed the author
The tool Pangram flagged 99 percent of the Peruvian novel Donde el agua trabaja by author David Silva Rojas as AI-generated. After verifying documents, the publisher Almadia backed the work, but the reliability of the detector remains disputed.
The tool Pangram flagged 99 percent of the award-winning novel Donde el agua trabaja by Peruvian author David Silva Rojas as AI-generated text. Pangram also attributed more than 80 percent of the author's other texts to AI. The publisher Almadia nevertheless stands behind the work after verifying documents from the author.
The case is being compared to the case of author Thelyson Orelien and to accusations surrounding the Caine Prize. The publishing house Gallimard plans to start screening manuscripts with the Pangram tool from next year. The organization Authors Guild warns that AI detectors should not become the sole basis for decision-making.
Why it matters
The case shows that AI text detection tools can produce high scores even in disputed cases. For authors and institutions, this means a risk of false accusations and the need not to rely on a single number from a detector.
Two audiences, two different impacts
What this means
For individuals
Authors may be incorrectly flagged as fraudsters by an AI detector, so it is useful to have records documenting one's own authorship.
For a business
Companies considering the deployment of AI detectors should not use the result as the sole basis for deciding on publication or sanctioning an author.
Risks and complianceCheck the original
Event sources
only one source so far · 1 publisher, 1 independent. We count feeds from the same owner only once.