Charter revocation as a possible tool for regulating AI companies in the US
An analysis by the AI Now Institute describes an old, today almost unused legal tool – state revocation of a corporate charter – as a theoretical possibility for regulating AI companies. Delaware, where these companies are incorporated, still has this right enshrined in its constitution.
The source describes a historical mechanism whereby US states granted corporations charters (founding documents) in exchange for fulfilling a public purpose, and could revoke them for abuse of powers. The constitution of the state of Delaware, where the companies mentioned in the report are incorporated, still contains this right today – the General Assembly is to revoke a corporation's charter for "abuse, misuse, or non-use" of its powers, and the relevant statute (Del. Code Ann. tit. 8, § 284(a)) gives courts the authority to decide on this.
According to the source, charter revocation is in practice rarely used, and courts regard it as a last resort reserved for serious misconduct, criminal activity, or sustained violations of the law – in past cases, courts have required a "continuing course of fraud, immorality, or illegality." The source quotes attorney Kevin Frazier, according to whom the increased risk of biological weapons could be serious enough to justify the state of Delaware revoking OpenAI's charter – however, according to the source, this is a theory that has not been tested in practice.
The source further mentions that OpenAI's charter could also be challengeable on another ground – namely that its for-profit operations exceed the scope of the original nonprofit corporation for which the charter was issued. The rest of the analysis on this point is not available in the source.
Why it matters
This is a legal-theoretical discussion, not an announced or ongoing regulatory action – no state or court has yet initiated charter revocation against a specific AI company. However, for tracking the development of AI regulation in the US, it is relevant that, alongside new laws, there are also considerations of using existing, as-yet-unused tools of corporate law.
Check the original
Event sources
only one source so far · 1 publisher, 1 independent. We count feeds from the same owner only once.